When does tact sink into fulsome cant? However, it is also subjective to the situation. As Goodman concedes, this might border on universalism, but "all politics is compromise," and establishing some basics for universality is a part of that element becoming so much more needed in a globalized setting than ever before.
That is easy to see and say but harder to live by or die for in practice, in the clinches: Yet compromise is the stuff of politics. View freely available titles: Although it may seem they should be universal, ethics are almost always subjective and relative to their current situation and cultural context.
As Goodman concedes, this might border on universalism, but "all politics is compromise," and establishing some basics for His argument in some cases lacks proper evidence and in other cases generalizes too much. Conceding that human norms must vary in their particulars from society to society and culture to culture, he scanned the traditions of India to help him sketch some norms worthy of universal support.
Goodman bio Some years ago I took part in an international meeting of philosophers. He may at first appear to construct a well thought out argument; however, in certain areas he falls short.
Review some moral minima the sexual abuse of young children is undeniably wrong, consenual sex between two people who are aware of their actions can not be listed in the same category, nor is it the same as a violent rape.
He or she deserves to die. Further to state that polygamy is the cause of such abuses is similar to saying that it is the gun which kills rather than the individual who uses it. And if lies are countenanced to spare a fugitive, can we debar other appeals to expedience—lying for political or personal ends, or pious fraud to aid others in this world or toward the next?
Goodman singles "out a few areas where I think human deserts are irrefragable — not because these deserts are never questioned or breached in practice, but because they never should be. They do not believe in child or spousal abuse, nor do they condone the act of child brides. Do the claims of truth, for instance, debar all lies?
Slavery is no doubt a heinous act which "keeps its victim alive while stripping her of agency. Child brides and abusive relationships may be a part of some polygamous acts, however it is a generalization to say that all polygamist families share in these abuses.
In many cases of statutory rape, the sexual act took place between two teenagers, close in age, yet one is slightly older. That is the very nature of war. As the world is becoming increasingly globalized, nations becoming interdependent on one another and isolationism is becoming less evident, it is important that all nations share some basic and fundamental values.Some Moral Minna By Lenn Goodman The Morally Right In “Some Moral Minima” I believe Lenn Goodman is right when he says certain things are simply wrong.
I agree with Goodman on the issues he discusses such as slavery, genocide, terrorism, murder, rape, polygamy, and incest. Some Moral Minima Lenn E. Goodman The Good Society, Volume 19, Number 1,pp.
(Article) Published by Penn State University Press DOI: For additional information about this article. The beliefs of Lenn Goodman are based on the history of moral knowledge and what many of us as Americans think are right (Goodman, ).
There should be universal moral requirements as we have witnessed over time throughout history. Some Moral Minima Review Ashford University. Jun 21, · A Review.
Lenn E. Goodman wrote the article Some Moral Minima in an attempt to point out certain morals that should be universal. War too, is an instance where in some cases the ends justify the means.
While genocide, which "targets individuals as members of a group. Get an answer for 'In "Some Moral Minima," Lenn Goodman argues that there are certain things that are simply wrong. Explain how this might be accurate.' and find homework help for other Philosophy. View Essay - Some Moral Minima Review from SOC SOC at Ashford University.
Some Moral Minima Review Some Moral Minima Review Angelica Farhat SOC Intro to Ethics & Social.Download